Start typing. Use the arrow keys to move and Enter to open. Press / anywhere to search.

Eugene Forsey and the Crown: Life, Books and Legacy

6 min read · Reviewed

Eugene Forsey (1904 to 1991) was a Canadian scholar, labour researcher and senator, and one of the country’s best-known constitutional authorities. He wrote the standard account of the Governor General’s power to dissolve Parliament and the guide to Canadian government that students still read, How Canadians Govern Themselves.

Key facts about Eugene Forsey

Item Detail
Born 29 May 1904
Died 20 February 1991, Ottawa
Education McGill University; Balliol College, Oxford, as a Rhodes Scholar
Career Economist and researcher for the Canadian Congress of Labour and the Canadian Labour Congress
Senate Appointed in 1970 and served until 1979, when he retired at 75
Honours Officer of the Order of Canada (1968), Companion (1988); sworn of the Privy Council in 1985
Best-known works The Royal Power of Dissolution of Parliament in the British Commonwealth, Freedom and Order (1974), How Canadians Govern Themselves, memoir A Life on the Fringe (1990)

A scholar who cared about how government works

Forsey was born in Newfoundland, then a separate dominion, and he studied at McGill before winning a Rhodes Scholarship to Oxford. He began on the political right, moved to democratic socialism at Oxford, and was a delegate at the founding convention of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation in 1933. He then built a long career in the labour movement, as research director for the Canadian Congress of Labour and later the Canadian Labour Congress.

He was never a simple partisan. In the early 1960s he left the New Democratic Party over its view of Quebec as a nation, and he later joined the Liberals. In 1982 he resigned from the Liberal Party over disagreements about the changes made to the Constitution that year. That independence helped his reputation as a commentator who could be read by all sides.

The King-Byng affair and the power of dissolution

Forsey’s doctoral work examined the King-Byng affair of 1926, in which Governor General Lord Byng refused Prime Minister Mackenzie King’s request to dissolve Parliament and called on the Conservative leader, Arthur Meighen, to form a government instead. Meighen’s government fell within days, and King won the election that followed. Many Canadians have since seen the episode as a defeat for the Crown. Forsey took the opposite view. He argued that Byng had acted within his constitutional rights and that a Governor General may sometimes refuse a prime minister’s request for dissolution.

The thesis became his book on the royal power of dissolution of Parliament in the British Commonwealth, published in 1943. The argument still shapes how the reserve powers of the Crown are discussed, including in more recent episodes such as the 2008 request to prorogue Parliament. For the general framework, see the facts about the monarchy and the Governor General and lieutenant governors.

Forsey in the Senate and public life

Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau appointed Forsey to the Senate in 1970, and he served as a senator for Ontario until 1979. Before that, in 1958, John Diefenbaker named him to the Board of Broadcast Governors, a post he left in 1962 over policy differences. He was a witness and a commentator during constitutional debates in the 1970s and 1980s, and he remained an advocate of Parliament as the centre of Canadian government.

His honours reflect his place in public life. He became an Officer of the Order of Canada in 1968 and a Companion in 1988, and in 1985 he was sworn of the Queen’s Privy Council. More on those honours is on the awards and honours page.

What he wrote for ordinary readers

How Canadians Govern Themselves is a short, plain guide to the Canadian system, from the origins of Parliament to the Charter, the Crown, the Senate, the Commons, parties, cabinet and the courts. The Library of Parliament has kept it updated since his death, and the Government of Canada has issued many editions, including a tenth in 2020. It is useful in classrooms because it explains the mechanics rather than arguing for a cause. Readers who want more teaching tools can find them on the education page.

Forsey on the Crown

Forsey held that the Crown is not a decoration. In his view it is a working part of Canada’s parliamentary democracy: it provides continuity, a non-partisan head of state, and a safeguard in rare moments when a government might try to bend the rules. He thought the arguments about the monarchy ought to be conducted with a knowledge of how the system actually works, which is the theme of Canada and the UK monarchy. Not everyone agrees with him, and the case against is outlined on the debate page.

Why Forsey still matters

Whenever a prime minister asks for an election or a prorogation, commentators return to Forsey’s writing. He gave Canadian readers a detailed, example-driven account of the reserve powers and of the conditions under which a Governor General may refuse advice. His work is cited by scholars of every opinion, which is the best measure of its lasting value.

Timeline of Forsey’s life

Year Event
1904 Born on 29 May
1933 Delegate at the founding convention of the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation
1943 Publishes his study of the royal power of dissolution
1958 Named to the Board of Broadcast Governors by John Diefenbaker; resigns in 1962
1968 Appointed an Officer of the Order of Canada
1970 Appointed to the Senate
1974 Publishes Freedom and Order
1979 Retires from the Senate at 75
1985 Sworn of the Queen’s Privy Council
1988 Promoted to Companion of the Order of Canada
1990 Publishes his memoir, A Life on the Fringe
1991 Dies on 20 February

Forsey’s arguments in modern cases

Several recent moments show why his writing is still read. In December 2008 the Governor General agreed to a request to prorogue Parliament while a coalition threatened to defeat the government, and in March 2025 the Governor General dissolved Parliament on the prime minister’s request, leading to the general election of 28 April 2025. In both episodes, commentators asked the questions Forsey had asked: when must a Governor General follow advice, and when may she or he hesitate? Anyone who wants to understand those debates can begin with his book and then read the myths about the monarchy.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Related reading:

Frequently asked questions

Who was Eugene Forsey?

He was a Canadian constitutional scholar, labour researcher and senator (1904 to 1991). He is best known for his writing on the Crown’s power to dissolve Parliament and for How Canadians Govern Themselves.

What did Forsey think of the King-Byng affair?

He defended Lord Byng’s decision, arguing that the Governor General acted within the constitution when refusing Mackenzie King a dissolution in 1926.

Was Eugene Forsey a senator?

Yes. He sat in the Senate for Ontario from 1970 until he retired in 1979.

Where can I read How Canadians Govern Themselves?

The Government of Canada publications catalogue lists the Library of Parliament editions, including the 2020 edition in PDF.

Sources and further reading