The royal prerogative is the leftover authority that the common law gives to the Crown, covering things such as making treaties, deploying the armed forces, issuing passports and granting honours. In Canada it is exercised in the King’s name but, by convention, almost always on the advice of ministers. The Governor General acts, and Cabinet decides.
Key facts
| Point | Short answer |
|---|---|
| Source | Common law, preserved by section 9 of the Constitution Act, 1867 |
| Holder in law | The Crown, meaning the King of Canada |
| Who decides in practice | The Prime Minister and Cabinet, or an individual minister |
| Who signs | The Governor General, for federal matters; lieutenant governors, for provincial ones |
| Can Parliament change it? | Yes, by passing a statute that regulates or replaces a power |
| Can courts review it? | Sometimes; Charter review is available, and “high policy” decisions are given wide room |
What the royal prerogative is and is not
Lawyers define the prerogative in two ways. The older definition, from the English jurist A. V. Dicey, calls it the residue of discretionary authority that is still legally left in the hands of the Crown. A broader one, favoured by Peter Hogg, counts every power and privilege the common law gives the Crown, including immunities such as the rule that a statute does not bind the Crown unless it says so. Canada’s Court of Appeal for Ontario accepted both in Black v. Chrétien (2001).
Two features matter. First, the prerogative is judge-made, so its content is not frozen in a list. Second, it is an executive power, not a legislative one. It lets government act without a new Act of Parliament, but it cannot create new crimes, impose taxes or override a statute.
It also does not mean that the King personally runs anything. Under responsible government the powers are held in his name and used by ministers who answer to the House of Commons. That is why the old phrase “at the pleasure of the Crown” and the modern fact of cabinet control sit side by side without contradiction. For the wider idea of what “the Crown” means in law, see the Crown in right of Canada.
Where the prerogative comes from in the Constitution
Canada did not write its prerogative from scratch. Part III of the Constitution Act, 1867 (sections 9 to 15) says that executive government and authority over Canada “continues and is vested in” the Sovereign, creates the Queen’s Privy Council for Canada, and gives the Governor General the powers that colonial governors had held. Section 13 explains that “Governor General in Council” means the Governor General acting with the advice of the Privy Council, which in practice means Cabinet. Section 15 keeps command-in-chief of the armed forces with the Sovereign.
The Letters Patent of 1947, issued by King George VI, then authorized the Governor General to exercise the King’s powers in respect of Canada. Since then the head of state’s functions have been carried out in Canada by the viceroy, as described in the page on the Governor General’s powers.
The office of the King, the Governor General and the lieutenant governors is also protected from change by an ordinary law. Section 41 of the Constitution Act, 1982 requires the unanimous agreement of Parliament and every provincial legislature to alter it.
Who really exercises the power?
Cabinet does. A paper on the subject from National Defence puts it plainly: the political executive, not the head of state, uses the prerogative. The Governor General is a legally necessary figure but acts on advice.
That decision can be made at several levels:
- Cabinet as a whole, usually formalized in an Order in Council or a record of decision.
- A cabinet committee, such as the one dealing with foreign affairs and national security.
- The Prime Minister, who may use the prerogative directly, as in the advice at issue in Black.
- An individual minister, for example the Minister of National Defence on certain international deployments.
Parliament has no legal role in most of this, although governments often consult it. Provinces work the same way: lieutenant governors act on the advice of their executive councils, and provincial premiers and cabinets hold the practical power in matters that fall within provincial jurisdiction.
Examples of prerogative powers in practice
The following list is not exhaustive, since the prerogative can shrink or be altered over time.
| Area | How it works today |
|---|---|
| Foreign affairs and treaties | The federal executive negotiates and ratifies treaties. Parliament does not have to approve ratification. A treaty that changes domestic law needs legislation, and where the subject belongs to the provinces under sections 91 and 92 of the 1867 Act, provincial statutes too. Since 2008 treaties have normally been tabled in the House of Commons before ratification as a matter of policy |
| War and peace | Declaring war and deploying the Canadian Armed Forces abroad are executive decisions. No vote is required. Governments have nonetheless held debates or votes, for instance on the Afghanistan mission in 2006 and the Iraq mission in 2014 |
| Honours | The Crown is the “fountain of honour”. The Order of Canada and other national honours were created through the prerogative and letters patent; see the honours system |
| Passports | Issued under the Canadian Passport Order, an order made by the Governor General in Council under the prerogative, not under a statute |
| Mercy | The power survives, but pardons and record suspensions are now handled mainly under the Criminal Code and the Criminal Records Act. Section 749 of the Criminal Code expressly preserves the prerogative of mercy |
| Appointments | Many appointments, such as ambassadors and certain commissions, are made by prerogative where no statute says otherwise. Senators and judges are appointed under statutory and constitutional provisions |
| Public inquiries and public lands | Historically prerogative matters, though much of this ground now has legislation attached to it |
Armed forces provide a useful example of how the layers fit together. The King is commander-in-chief under section 15, the Governor General holds that title in his name, and decisions about missions come from ministers. The page on the Crown and the Canadian Armed Forces covers the military side in more detail. The National Defence Act then adds statutory machinery, such as the power to place the forces on active service.
Reserve powers versus ordinary prerogative
People often use “prerogative” for two separate things. Most prerogative powers are routine and used on ministerial advice every week: signing an Order in Council, ratifying a treaty, issuing a passport.
A small group, called reserve powers, are the ones where the Governor General may have to use personal judgment. They include appointing a Prime Minister when the result of an election is unclear, deciding whether to grant a request to dissolve Parliament, and the final decision to give or withhold Royal Assent. Even here, the convention is that the viceroy follows the advice of a Prime Minister who holds the confidence of the House of Commons, with narrow exceptions.
Cases where this was tested include the 1926 King-Byng affair, the 2008 and 2020 prorogations, and the 2025 prorogation, which are covered on the page about prorogation and dissolution. Since 2007 the Canada Elections Act has set fixed election dates, but it expressly leaves the Governor General’s discretion to dissolve Parliament untouched.
How statute and courts limit the prerogative
Statute
Parliament can limit the prerogative or replace it altogether. In the English case Attorney General v. De Keyser’s Royal Hotel (1920), the House of Lords held that once a statute covers the same ground, the Crown must follow the statute and cannot rely on the older power. Canadian courts apply the same logic. A statute can regulate how a power is used, as many statutes about honours or the forces do. Or it can displace the power entirely, which is rarer.
Courts
For a long time the courts treated prerogative decisions as outside their reach. That changed with two decisions.
In Council of Civil Service Unions v. Minister for the Civil Service (the GCHQ case, 1984), the House of Lords held that what mattered was the subject of a decision, not whether it came from statute or prerogative. A decision that affected a person’s rights or legitimate expectations could be reviewed.
In Operation Dismantle v. The Queen (1985), the Supreme Court of Canada held that Cabinet decisions, including prerogative ones, are subject to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The case was a challenge to the testing of American cruise missiles in Canada. The challenge failed because the alleged harm was too speculative, but the principle stood.
Later cases put detail on this. Black v. Chrétien (2001) held that advice on honours was not reviewable by the court, and it described a spectrum of justiciability where “high policy” decisions, such as signing treaties or declaring war, sit at the far end. In Canada (Prime Minister) v. Khadr (2010), the Supreme Court found that Canada had taken part in a breach of Omar Khadr’s Charter rights at Guantanamo Bay. It held that the foreign affairs prerogative must be used in line with the Charter, but because the government is best placed to judge diplomatic matters, it gave only a declaration instead of ordering a particular remedy. The court in Black also treated decisions such as passport refusals as open to review, since they affect individual rights.
Calls to change the prerogative
Some Canadian MPs have introduced private members’ bills that would require parliamentary approval before troops are sent abroad or treaties are ratified, and Senate committees have asked for a bigger role at times. Supporters argue that decisions of that weight should have a democratic check. Others reply that Cabinet is already answerable to the Commons and that flexibility in foreign and security policy has real value. The current rule remains that these powers sit with the executive.
The prerogative is also a place where the myth that the King personally governs breaks down. The monarch’s role is symbolic and constitutional. The practical decisions belong to ministers elected to the House of Commons, which is why the head of state and head of government are different people, a distinction explained on the page about Canada’s head of state.
Last reviewed: November 2026.
Related reading:
Frequently asked questions
What does royal prerogative mean in simple terms?
It is the set of powers that the common law has long given the Crown, such as making treaties or granting honours, which the government can use without passing a new law. In Canada these powers are used on ministers’ advice.
Does the King of Canada personally use the royal prerogative?
No. The Governor General exercises the King’s powers in Canada, and does so on the advice of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. Only a small set of reserve powers leave real personal judgment to the viceroy.
Can Canada go to war without a vote in Parliament?
Legally, yes. Deploying the armed forces is a prerogative power held by the executive, and no vote is required. In practice governments have sometimes put a motion to the House of Commons, but that is a political choice rather than a legal duty.
Can a court overturn a prerogative decision?
In some cases. Since Operation Dismantle (1985), prerogative decisions can be tested against the Charter, and Khadr (2010) confirmed this for foreign affairs. Courts remain cautious on matters of high policy such as treaties and war.
Is the prerogative of mercy still used?
It still exists in law, and the Criminal Code preserves it in section 749. Most cases are now handled through statutory record suspensions and the pardon provisions of the Criminal Code and the Criminal Records Act.
Sources and further reading
- Introduction and the Law of the Crown Prerogative, National Defence (canada.ca)
- Prerogative Powers, The Canadian Encyclopedia
- Constitution Act, 1867, Part III: Executive Power (Justice Laws Website)
- Royal prerogative, Wikipedia
For the viceregal side of the story, see also the Governors General of Canada, lieutenant governors and the broader facts about the Canadian monarchy.