Start typing. Use the arrow keys to move and Enter to open. Press / anywhere to search.

Forming Government in Canada: Confidence and Minorities

10 min read · Reviewed

In Canada the Governor General invites the person who can hold the confidence of the House of Commons to form the government, usually the leader of the party with the most seats. That person becomes Prime Minister. After dissolution, a caretaker convention limits what ministers do until the result is clear.

Key facts

Item Detail
Who formally appoints the Prime Minister The Governor General, in the King’s name
Test for forming government Ability to command the confidence of the House of Commons
Legal basis Convention; not in a statute or the Standing Orders
What happens after a defeat on confidence The government resigns or asks for dissolution
Federal minority governments since 1921 13, according to The Canadian Encyclopedia
Caretaker guidance Privy Council Office, Guidelines on the conduct of Ministers, 2025 edition dated 24 March 2025
Most recent election 28 April 2025: Liberals 169, Conservatives 144, Bloc Québécois 22, NDP 7, Green 1

Who forms the government in Canada?

The short answer is the House of Commons, indirectly. Canadians do not vote for a Prime Minister. They elect members of Parliament, and the person who leads the government is the one the members will support. The Governor General’s role is to make sure that someone is in the job who can govern with the House’s backing. The Library of Parliament’s 2025 study of the transition to the 45th Parliament puts it this way: MPs decide which party, or parties, will hold their confidence.

The party with the most seats usually forms the government, but that is a custom and not a rule. In the 1925 election the Conservatives won 116 seats and the Liberals 101, yet Mackenzie King stayed in office for months because he kept the support of the Progressives. The test was the House, not the seat count.

The steps after an election usually run like this:

  1. If one party clearly wins a majority, the Prime Minister of the outgoing government either stays on or resigns and advises the Governor General to call on the leader of the winning party.
  2. In a close result, the incumbent Prime Minister is generally given the first opportunity to meet the House and test its confidence, while the Governor General waits for advice and does not make a choice for political reasons.
  3. The person invited to form a government is sworn in as Prime Minister, picks ministers who are sworn in at Rideau Hall, and recalls Parliament.
  4. The government’s first test is usually the vote on the Address in Reply to the Speech from the Throne.

The Governor General acts for the King, a relationship described in the powers of the Governor General. The reserve power to choose a Prime Minister when the outcome is unclear is part of the royal prerogative. This page deals with the convention that guides the choice. The page on prorogation and dissolution deals with how the Crown’s other powers over the life of Parliament work in practice, and it is worth reading beside this one: prorogation and dissolution.

What is the confidence convention?

The government, meaning the Prime Minister and Cabinet, must have the support of a majority of the House of Commons to stay in office. According to House of Commons Procedure and Practice, this is a matter of tradition and is not in any statute or Standing Order. It applies whether the government is a majority, a coalition or a minority.

What counts as a confidence vote is not always clear and the Speaker cannot rule on it. The generally accepted categories are:

  • an explicit motion stating that the House has or has not confidence in the government
  • a motion the government itself declares to be a confidence question
  • implicit votes, such as the vote on the Address in Reply to the Speech from the Throne, on the budget, and on spending (supply) motions

If a government loses such a vote, it is expected to resign or to ask for dissolution so that an election can be held. Defeats are uncommon. According to House of Commons Procedure and Practice, no government has been defeated on the Address in Reply since Confederation. Joe Clark’s minority government fell in December 1979 after Social Credit withheld its support in a confidence vote, and Paul Martin’s government was defeated by an opposition motion in 2005. Stephen Harper’s minority government was toppled by a confidence motion in 2011.

The convention is what ties the Crown to elected politics. The sovereign’s representative has formal power over the executive, but responsible government means ministers must answer to elected members. How that principle was won is part of the timeline of the Canadian monarchy, and its legal framework is described in the Constitution Act, 1867 and the Crown.

How do minority governments work?

A minority government has fewer than half the seats in the House of Commons but still has the confidence of the House. The Canadian Encyclopedia counts 13 federal minority governments since the first in 1921. They need votes from other parties on each confidence measure, which can come by case-by-case bargaining or through a written agreement, such as the supply and confidence arrangements some parties have signed in exchange for policy commitments.

Minorities are often short but not always unproductive. Lester Pearson’s minority governments between 1963 and 1968 passed legislation creating the Canada Pension Plan and national health insurance, with NDP support. Stephen Harper governed in a minority from 2006 to 2011. The Liberals under Justin Trudeau governed in minority after the 2019 and 2021 elections.

Canada has had no formal peacetime coalition since 1867. The only coalition government was the wartime Union government of 1917 to 1921, according to The Canadian Encyclopedia.

What is the caretaker convention?

When Parliament is dissolved for an election, the government stays in office but cannot know whether the new House will back it. The caretaker convention says it should act with restraint until the outcome is clear. No separate caretaker government is appointed. The sitting Prime Minister and ministers simply continue in a more limited mode.

The Privy Council Office sets out the rules in its Guidelines on the conduct of Ministers, Ministers of State, exempt staff and public servants during an election. The 2025 edition is dated 24 March 2025, the day after Parliament was dissolved. Its main points are these.

Topic What the guidelines say
When it starts When the government loses a non-confidence vote, or when Parliament is dissolved
When it ends When a new government is sworn in, or when the election result clearly returns the incumbent
Test for action Matters should be routine, non-controversial, urgent and in the public interest, reversible by a new government without undue cost, or agreed to by the opposition parties
Appointments Normally deferred; the Prime Minister’s Office and the PCO must be consulted if one cannot wait
Spending and contracts Routine items continue with extra care; non-routine decisions are deferred
International business High-profile visits and signing of agreements should be avoided; irreversible steps such as ratification are to be avoided
Advertising and research Government advertising is generally curtailed; public opinion research is suspended from the day the writ is issued unless approved as necessary
Crown corporations Not bound, but encouraged to follow the principles

Nothing in law compels compliance. It is a convention enforced by the opposition, the media and the expectations of the Governor General. If the incumbent loses and there is no clear successor, the guidelines say the caretaker period lasts until a new government is sworn in. That can take several weeks. Crown corporations are covered on the page about Crown corporations.

King-Byng 1926: a short case study

The most famous test of these ideas came in 1926. Mackenzie King’s minority government, which depended on Progressive support, faced a vote on a customs scandal. On 26 June he asked Governor General Lord Byng for dissolution to avoid the vote. On 28 June Byng declined to sign the order. King resigned, and Byng asked Arthur Meighen, the Conservative leader, to form a government. Meighen’s ministry lost a no-confidence vote by one vote on 2 July, and Byng then granted him a dissolution. King won the most seats in the election on 14 September and led a minority government again.

Historians still debate whether Byng was right to refuse. The affair is part of the process described on the independence page, and it left a strong preference that a Governor General should follow the advice of a Prime Minister who holds the House’s confidence.

2008: the coalition threat

In December 2008 the Liberals and NDP, with the Bloc Québécois offering support, proposed to replace the Conservative minority after a fiscal update. Prime Minister Harper asked Governor General Michaëlle Jean to prorogue Parliament on 4 December, and she agreed until 26 January 2009. The episode reopened the question of whether a Prime Minister facing a likely defeat may use the Crown to avoid the House. The full account is in prorogation and dissolution.

2025: from Carney’s swearing-in to a majority

The most recent example shows many of the rules in one sequence.

  • 14 March 2025: Mark Carney was sworn in as the 24th Prime Minister, succeeding Justin Trudeau, and appointed the 30th Canadian Ministry the same day.
  • 23 March 2025: Carney presented Governor General Mary Simon with advice to dissolve Parliament, and she approved it. The caretaker convention applied from that point, under the guidelines dated the next day.
  • 28 April 2025: The Liberals won 169 of the 343 seats, three short of the 172 needed for a majority. The Conservatives won 144, the Bloc Québécois 22, the New Democratic Party 7 and the Green Party 1. It was the Liberals’ third consecutive minority.
  • 27 May 2025: King Charles III opened the 45th Parliament in person and read the Speech from the Throne, as described in the 2025 royal visit.

The standings then changed. Between November 2025 and April 2026, five MPs moved to the Liberal caucus, four from the Conservatives and one from the NDP, and the Liberals won three by-elections on 13 April 2026. According to Wikipedia’s page on the 45th Parliament, the Liberals held 173 seats on 23 September 2026, with six seats vacant. The change from minority to majority took place without an election, which is allowed because the confidence convention looks at the House as it stands. The seat count changes with by-elections and defections, so the House of Commons website is the place to check the current numbers.

On 8 June 2026, Louise Arbour became Governor General, as listed in the list of governors general. The office is explained in the Governor General overview.

How is this different from the royal prerogative?

The royal prerogative is the body of legal powers that belong to the Crown, such as appointing ministers, dissolving Parliament and making treaties. Conventions such as confidence and caretaker rules are the political customs that decide how those powers are used. The law says the Governor General appoints the Prime Minister. The convention says it must be the person who can hold the House. The first is law, and the second is practice that courts do not enforce. See the royal prerogative for the legal powers and the Crown in right of Canada for the structure behind them.

Related reading:

Frequently asked questions

Does the party with the most seats always form the government?

No. It usually does, but the test is confidence. A party with fewer seats can govern if it can win the House’s support, as King did after the 1925 election.

Who chooses the Prime Minister of Canada?

The Governor General appoints the Prime Minister, on the convention that the choice must be the person who can command the confidence of the House of Commons. The voters choose MPs, not the Prime Minister directly.

What is a caretaker government?

It is the government in office between dissolution and the time a new government is sworn in or the result clearly returns the incumbent. It is expected to limit itself to routine, urgent or reversible business.

What happens if a government loses a confidence vote?

It is expected to resign or ask the Governor General for dissolution. The Governor General may consider whether another party can govern, but in modern practice an election has followed.

Can a minority government become a majority without an election?

In practice yes, if enough MPs join the governing caucus or the government wins by-elections. That happened in 2026 when the Liberals reached a narrow majority.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Sources and further reading