Start typing. Use the arrow keys to move and Enter to open. Press / anywhere to search.

What Is a Royal Commission in Canada? How Inquiries Work

11 min read · Reviewed

A royal commission in Canada is a major federal inquiry ordered by the Governor in Council, meaning Cabinet acting through the Governor General, under Part I of the Inquiries Act. Commissioners can summon witnesses and take evidence under oath, but their reports are advice only. The word “royal” comes from the Crown’s prerogative, not from any royal involvement.

Key facts

Item Detail
Legal basis Inquiries Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-11, Part I (sections 2 to 5)
Who creates one The Governor in Council, by order in council and a commission issued under the Great Seal
Powers Summon witnesses, take sworn evidence, require documents, hire counsel and experts
Binding? No. Findings and recommendations have no legal force
Who decides on publication Cabinet decides whether to make a report public, and most are tabled in the House of Commons
Scale Close to 450 federal commissions of inquiry since Confederation, according to the Canadian Encyclopedia
Records Filed with the Clerk of the Privy Council and then transferred to Library and Archives Canada

What is a royal commission?

A royal commission is a formal, temporary body set up to investigate a matter of national importance and report on it. The Privy Council Office describes commissions of inquiry as bodies set up to investigate “issues of national importance” fully and impartially. They are headed by judges, experts or other distinguished people, and they are given terms of reference that define the question, the powers and usually a finishing date.

Commissions fall into two broad kinds. Advisory commissions have a wide mandate so they can weigh options and consult everyone with an interest. Investigative commissions have a narrower task, such as finding out what happened in a particular event or program. Many Canadians think of the royal commission as the standard form, but the same powers are available to commissions that carry another title.

Who creates a royal commission and under what law?

The federal power comes from the Inquiries Act. Under section 2, the Governor in Council may order an inquiry into any matter connected with the good government of Canada or the conduct of federal public business whenever it considers this expedient. Under section 3, it may appoint commissioners by commission to carry it out. The Governor in Council is the Governor General acting on the advice of the federal Cabinet, a concept explained on the page about the Governor in Council. In practice the Prime Minister and Cabinet decide, and the Governor General signs the order.

Sections 4 and 5 give commissioners powers to summon witnesses, receive evidence under oath or affirmation, and require documents. Section 5 says they have the same power to compel attendance and testimony as a superior court of record has in civil cases. Section 11 lets them hire counsel, experts and staff, and section 13 protects individuals: no report may be made against a person until they have had reasonable notice of the alleged misconduct and a full chance to respond.

Part II covers departmental investigations, where a minister, with Governor in Council authority, appoints commissioners to look into the management of a department and the conduct of its staff. Many other federal statutes, at least 87 by the Canadian Encyclopedia’s count, also give inquiry powers to particular bodies. The Act dates from 1868, soon after Confederation.

Why is it called royal?

The name reflects where the power came from. The Canadian Encyclopedia traces the royal commission to the monarch’s prerogative to order investigations, and it points to a 1517 commission on enclosures under Henry VIII as a likely early prototype. A Canadian royal commission is created under the Great Seal of Canada, and the Crown remains the formal source of authority. See the royal prerogative for the wider background and the Crown in right of Canada for how the Crown acts through ministers.

None of this means the King or Governor General takes part. The Canadian Encyclopedia notes that royal commissions are “no more regal” than other inquiries, because the powers they have are the same. Prestige is the main difference. Royal commissions are usually kept for the gravest national issues, and the Law Reform Commission of Canada once recommended dropping the term altogether.

Royal commission, public inquiry or task force?

The three terms overlap, and the line is blurry in practice.

Body Typical use Appointed by Members
Royal commission Broad policy questions or grave national issues Governor in Council Prominent chair and commissioners
Public inquiry or commission of inquiry A specific event, scandal or failure Governor in Council under the Inquiries Act, or under another statute Often a single judge
Task force Practical study of a defined problem, often by a department Usually a minister or department Practitioners and officials

The Canadian Encyclopedia notes that task forces are normally made up of practitioners rather than prominent public figures and are often appointed by departments. It also notes that some task forces have tackled broad topics and some royal commissions have examined single incidents, so the labels follow custom more than law. Modern federal inquiries are usually titled a commission of inquiry or a public inquiry, and the Inquiries Act treats them alike.

Notable Canadian royal commissions and inquiries

The table lists some of the best-known commissions with their years and chairs. Not every entry carries the word “royal” in its title; where the formal title says commission of inquiry, that is stated.

Commission Years Chair or commissioner Known for
Royal Commission on Dominion-Provincial Relations (Rowell-Sirois) 1937 to 1940 N. W. Rowell, then Joseph Sirois Recommended a major shift of taxing and social powers to Ottawa; war and provincial opposition blocked much of it
Royal Commission on National Development in the Arts, Letters and Sciences (Massey) 1949 to 1951 Vincent Massey Led to the Canada Council for the Arts (1957) and the National Library (1953)
Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism (Laurendeau-Dunton) 1963 to 1970 André Laurendeau and Davidson Dunton Fed into the Official Languages Act of 1969
Royal Commission on the Status of Women 1967 to 1970 Florence Bird Studied the position of women in Canadian society
Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada (Macdonald) 1982 to 1985 Donald S. Macdonald Backed free trade talks with the United States
Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples 1991 to 1996 René Dussault and Georges Erasmus Five volumes, about 4,000 pages and 440 recommendations
Commission of Inquiry on the Blood System in Canada (Krever) 1993 to 1997 Horace Krever Inquiry into tainted blood
Commission of Inquiry into the Sponsorship Program (Gomery) 2004 to 2006 John Gomery Federal advertising and sponsorship spending
Public Order Emergency Commission 2022 to 2023 Paul Rouleau Review of the Emergencies Act declaration
Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes 2023 to 2025 Marie-Josée Hogue Review of foreign interference in federal elections

A few of these deserve a closer look. The Massey Commission, appointed on 8 April 1949 by Prime Minister Louis St-Laurent, held 114 public meetings in 16 cities and heard about 1,200 witnesses before reporting on 1 June 1951. The Bilingualism and Biculturalism commission was created in July 1963 under Prime Minister Lester Pearson, and its preliminary report appeared in 1965. The Macdonald commission recommended pursuing a free trade agreement with the United States, and the Mulroney government opened trade negotiations soon after its report. The Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples came out of the tensions after the Oka crisis and the failure of the Meech Lake Accord. The commission reported in November 1996, and the wider relationship is discussed on the page about the Crown and Indigenous peoples.

Is the Truth and Reconciliation Commission a royal commission?

No. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada was created in 2008 as part of the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement, a legal settlement among survivors, the Assembly of First Nations, church bodies and the Government of Canada. It was not a Cabinet inquiry under the Inquiries Act, and it lacked subpoena powers. Murray Sinclair chaired it from 2009, and it finished in December 2015, after publishing 94 Calls to Action in a summary report earlier that year. Many people describe it loosely as a commission of inquiry, which is why it is sometimes mistaken for a royal commission. The Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples, by contrast, was a federal royal commission from 1991 to 1996.

Recent federal public inquiries

Two recent inquiries show how the system works today. Both are commissions of inquiry set up by Cabinet, and neither carries the royal title.

The Public Order Emergency Commission was established in April 2022 when Justice Paul Rouleau was appointed commissioner. It looked at the circumstances that led the government to declare a public order emergency in February 2022 and at the measures taken. Public hearings ran from 13 October to 2 December 2022, and the five-volume report was released on 17 February 2023. Rouleau concluded that the government had met the very high threshold for invoking the Emergencies Act, but he said he reached the conclusion with reluctance and that reasonable people could disagree. The courts later looked at the same question separately. The Federal Court found the invocation unreasonable in 2024, and the dispute went on to appeal, so the legal story may not be finished. This is a reminder that an inquiry’s conclusions and a court’s ruling on the same events are different things, answering different questions.

The Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes and Democratic Institutions was announced on 7 September 2023, when the government issued the order in council setting its terms of reference and appointing Justice Marie-Josée Hogue as commissioner. Her work was set to begin on 18 September 2023. The federal government said all recognized parties in the House of Commons agreed to the terms of reference and the appointment. The final report, in seven volumes, was published on 28 January 2025. Ministers said it found that the 2019 and 2021 federal elections were free and fair. News coverage of the report adds that it made 51 recommendations and named China as the most active state source of interference, followed by India. Parties and commentators drew different conclusions from it, and the government said it would review the recommendations.

Do provinces have royal commissions?

Yes. Each province has its own inquiry statute, and the provincial cabinet, acting through the lieutenant governor, appoints commissions in the same pattern as the federal system. Ontario, for example, has a Public Inquiries Act, 2009. The Canadian Encyclopedia counts 199 royal commissions and commissions of inquiry in Ontario between 1867 and 1991, and education was the most common subject of provincial inquiries. See the page on the lieutenant governors for the office that signs provincial orders.

Joint inquiries are possible too. The Mass Casualty Commission was created on 21 October 2020 by the federal and Nova Scotia governments together to examine the April 2020 mass shooting in Nova Scotia. Its three commissioners were J. Michael MacDonald, Leanne Fitch and Kim Stanton. The final report arrived on 30 March 2023 with 130 recommendations, more than half aimed at the RCMP.

How are royal commission reports published?

Cabinet decides whether a report is made public, according to the Privy Council Office, and most are tabled in the House of Commons when released and then made available to the public. Part I commissions count as departments for financial administration purposes, and the Prime Minister is often assigned responsibility for them so the Privy Council Office can give administrative support. Records go to the Clerk of the Privy Council at the end and then to Library and Archives Canada.

Governments do not have to act. The Canadian Encyclopedia warns that governments often ignore reports whatever their merit, and critics say commissions can be used to delay a decision while public anger cools. Others reply that commissions expose misconduct and inform debate even when the recommendations sit unused. The Rowell-Sirois proposals and the Massey proposals offer a contrast: the first was largely blocked, while the second shaped Canadian cultural institutions within a decade. Cost is part of the debate: the Canadian Encyclopedia gives about $60 million for the Aboriginal peoples commission.

Related reading: Support for the Monarchy in Canada, What Is the Speech from the Throne in Canada?

Frequently asked questions

Who can create a royal commission in Canada?

At the federal level, the Governor in Council, meaning Cabinet acting through the Governor General, under section 2 and section 3 of the Inquiries Act. Provincial cabinets create provincial commissions under provincial laws.

Does a royal commission have to be approved by Parliament?

No. It is created by order in council without a parliamentary vote. Reports are usually tabled in the House of Commons, but the creation of the commission is an executive decision.

Can the government ignore a royal commission report?

Yes. The recommendations are not binding. Some reports shaped major policies, while others were largely set aside.

Is the King involved in a royal commission?

No. The commission is issued in the Crown’s name under the Great Seal, but the decisions are made by ministers. The Governor General acts on the advice of Cabinet.

What is the difference between a royal commission and a public inquiry?

The powers are the same under the Inquiries Act. A royal commission usually has a broader policy question and several commissioners, while a public inquiry often examines a specific event and is led by a single judge.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Sources and further reading