Canada has no single code of succession of its own. The rules come from British statutes such as the Act of Settlement, 1701, which Canada received as law, and they have been confirmed and altered by Canadian acts, notably the Succession to the Throne Act of 1937 and the Succession to the Throne Act, 2013. Scholars still disagree on how they may be changed.
Key points
- Succession follows the Act of Settlement, 1701, the Bill of Rights, 1689, the common law and the 2013 reforms, which Canada assented to by statute.
- The Statute of Westminster, 1931 expects the assent of the Dominion Parliaments to a change in the succession, and since 1982 no British act can extend to Canada as part of its law.
- The Succession to the Throne Act, 2013 (Bill C-53) received royal assent on 27 March 2013 and came into force on 26 March 2015.
- Courts in Ontario and Quebec have dismissed challenges to the 2013 act, and the Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal in 2020.
- Whether a change needs the unanimous consent procedure of section 41(a) of the Constitution Act, 1982 remains debated among scholars.
Received law before the Statute of Westminster
Until 1931 the Parliament of the United Kingdom alone could legislate for the colonies and Dominions on the succession. Laws passed under that authority, among them the Bill of Rights, the Act of Settlement and the Royal Marriages Act, 1772, became part of Canadian law as “received law”. With English common law, such as the rule of male-preference primogeniture, they formed the Canadian rules.
The Constitution Act, 1867 does not set out who is Sovereign. Its preamble speaks of a constitution “similar in Principle to that of the United Kingdom”, and section 9 vests executive authority in the Queen, today the King. The assumption was that the person who is Sovereign of the United Kingdom is Sovereign of Canada.
Two readings of the position
One reading is that these rules are Canadian law, received and then confirmed by Canadian statute. The other, favoured by successive governments, is that succession is a matter of UK law which Canada recognises, and that there is no Canadian law of succession as such. The distinction matters because it decides who can change the rules and by what procedure.
The practical record favours the first reading in at least one respect. In 1952 the Queen’s Privy Council for Canada issued a proclamation of Elizabeth II’s accession on 6 February, the day she acceded, and the Crown passed to her in Canada at the same moment as in Britain. Canada did not have to wait for a British proclamation to know who its Sovereign was, because both countries’ rules produced the same person. The accession of Charles III in September 2022 followed the same pattern, as described on the page on Queen Elizabeth II.
The Statute of Westminster, 1931
The Statute’s preamble records two ideas. Because the Crown is the symbol of the free association of the members of the Commonwealth, any change in the law touching the succession or the royal style and titles should require the assent of the Parliaments of all the Dominions as well as the United Kingdom. And no later British law should extend to a Dominion without its request and consent, a rule made binding by section 4.
A preamble guides interpretation but does not bind in the way a section does. So the assent of the Dominions was a convention, while the request and consent was a legal condition for a British act to apply in a Dominion. In 1982, item 17 of the schedule to the Constitution Act, 1982 repealed section 4 as it applied to Canada, and section 2 of the Canada Act, 1982 provides that no British act passed after that date will extend to Canada as part of its law. The effect is that Canada can no longer request and consent to a British succession act. Changes must be made in Canada.
The abdication of 1936 and the Succession to the Throne Act, 1937
The only change to the succession needing legislation between 1931 and 2013 was the abdication of Edward VIII.
- On 10 December 1936 the King signed his Instrument of Abdication.
- Parliament was not sitting, so the Canadian Government gave Canada’s request and consent by order-in-council.
- On 11 December 1936 the British Parliament passed His Majesty’s Declaration of Abdication Act, 1936, reciting Canada’s request and consent.
- On 31 March 1937 the Parliament of Canada passed the Succession to the Throne Act, assenting to the change.
The Canadian Act reproduces the British act and the instrument in its schedules. Section 1 of the British act provides that the next in succession, George VI, succeeds, that Edward and any descendants have no right to the throne and that the Royal Marriages Act does not apply to them. A reasonable argument holds that this put the rules of the Act of Settlement and the Royal Marriages Act into Canadian statute law, a method similar to that used for the Constitution Act, 1982, which entered Canadian law through a UK statute. The abdication story is part of the royal history on the list of sovereigns, and the sovereign’s later title in the page on royal style and titles.
The 2013 reforms and the Canadian act
At the Perth meeting of Commonwealth leaders on 28 October 2011, the realms agreed to end male preference and to allow the Sovereign and heirs to marry Catholics. The substance of the reforms is explained on the page on the rules of succession.
Canada’s contribution was the Succession to the Throne Act, 2013, S.C. 2013, c. 6. Introduced as Bill C-53 by Justice Minister Rob Nicholson on 31 January 2013, it passed the House of Commons on 4 February and the Senate on 26 March without amendment, and received royal assent on 27 March 2013. It gives the assent of the Parliament of Canada to the British bill. The Governor General in Council brought it into force on 26 March 2015, to match the United Kingdom and other realms.
What the Government argued
The Government said no constitutional amendment was needed, since succession is governed by UK law and is not listed among the instruments of the Constitution of Canada. In its view, the assent of Parliament met the expectation of the Statute of Westminster, and the changes did not affect the “office of the Queen” within the meaning of section 41(a).
What critics argued
Scholars including Peter Hogg and Philippe Lagassé argued that changes to the succession affect the monarch’s office and so require the provinces’ consent under section 41(a). Anne Twomey described the government’s approach as a “de-patriation” of the Canadian constitution. Others, including Mark Walters, supported the government’s position. The difference is about what “in relation to the office” covers: the Sovereign’s powers and status, or also the question of who holds the office.
The courts
Ordinary Canadian courts have so far backed the Government’s practical position, without answering every constitutional question.
| Case | Court | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| O’Donohue v. Canada | Ontario Superior Court (2003) | The Act of Settlement is part of Canadian law and was not subject to Charter review, so a Charter challenge to its Catholic bar failed |
| Teskey | Ontario Superior Court (9 August 2013), Court of Appeal for Ontario (August 2014) | Challenge to the 2013 act dismissed |
| Motard | Quebec Superior Court (16 February 2016), Quebec Court of Appeal (28 October 2019) | Challenge dismissed; Canada did not need to alter its laws or constitution |
| Motard | Supreme Court of Canada | Leave to appeal refused on 23 April 2020 |
These decisions do not say that Parliament may change the succession alone. They show that the courts have declined to strike down the 2013 act.
Section 41(a) or section 44?
Section 41(a) requires resolutions of the Senate, the House of Commons and every provincial assembly for an amendment about “the office of the Queen, the Governor General and the Lieutenant Governor of a province”. Section 44 lets Parliament amend the Constitution in relation to the federal executive government and the Houses of Parliament, subject to section 41. The question is which applies. A reading of section 41(a) as covering both the office and its succession would put any change on the unanimous path, which is also the path for abolishing the Crown, the subject of the monarchy debate. A narrower reading would let Parliament act alone.
The 2013 episode left this unresolved. The government’s view was acted on and not overturned, but a Supreme Court of Canada ruling on the amending formula has not clearly settled it. It could be tested again if the realms were asked to remove someone from the line, such as in the discussion in 2025 and 2026 about Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. Canada’s government has said it would support such a move. Any new Canadian act would likely follow the 2013 model: a bill giving Parliament’s assent to British legislation.
Why it matters
The legal structure helps to explain why the King of Canada is both the same person as the King of the United Kingdom and the holder of a separate office. The shared line is a matter of agreement among realms, each acting through its own law. Readers interested in the structure of the Canadian Crown can start with the page on Canada and the UK monarchy, and those interested in how independence developed can read the page on independence.
Related reading: What Is the Speech from the Throne in Canada?
Frequently asked questions
Does Canada have its own law of succession?
Partly. The core rules come from received British law, and Canada has confirmed and changed them by statute, in the Succession to the Throne Act of 1937 and the Succession to the Throne Act, 2013.
Can the British Parliament change the rules for Canada?
No. Under section 2 of the Canada Act, 1982 no British act passed after 1982 extends to Canada as part of its law, so Canada must act through its own Parliament.
When did Canada approve the 2013 reforms?
The Succession to the Throne Act, 2013 received royal assent on 27 March 2013, and the Governor General in Council brought it into force on 26 March 2015.
Did the courts uphold the change?
Challenges in Ontario and Quebec were dismissed, and the Supreme Court of Canada refused leave to appeal in the Motard case on 23 April 2020.
Is unanimous provincial consent needed to change the succession?
That is the unresolved question. The Government said no, and some scholars said yes under section 41(a). The courts have not decided it in terms.
Last reviewed: November 2026